Vancomycin-Resistant Enterococci (VRE) Infections : surveillance results 2014–2015

From April 1, 2014, to March 31, 2015, 89 healthcare facilities took part in the surveillance of healthcare-associated vancomycin-resistant enterococci (VRE) infections, for a combined total of 4,839,578 patient days (Table 1). In total, 87 VRE infections were reported among patients who contracted strain during a current or previous hospital stay in the reporting facility (categories 1a + 1b). The incidence rate of healthcare-associated VRE infections (cat. 1a + 1b) was 0.18 / 10,000 patient days. This incidence rate was stable since 2013-2014. The acquisition rate of healthcare-associated VRE colonization (cat. 1a + 1b) was 10.99 / 10,000 patient days. Data was extracted on May 20th, 2015 and updated on June 1, 2015 for complications.

Updated : February 24,2016

Table 1 – Participation of Healthcare Facilities in the Surveillance of VRE Infections, Québec, 2011–2012 to 2014-2015

 2011-2012*2012-20132013-20142014-2015
Participating facilities (N)89898989
Admissions (N)356,104640,421643,933644,259
Inpatient days (N)2,811,4285,011,8494,901,3184,839,578
Cases of healthcare-associated VRE infection (cat. 1a + 1b) (N)3041**94¥87¥
Cases of helthcare-associated VRE colonization (cat. 1a + 1b) (N)1,9584,1455,3175,317

* The data for 2011–2012 are incomplete, as surveillance was initiated on September 11, 2011.Categories 1a and 1b refer to the acquisition of the strain, not the infection.
**The source of acquisition of the strain is unknown in 66 cases involving patients already colonized with VRE.
¥ In 2013-2014, VRE infections included known VRE carriers that developed infection.

In 2014–2015, the incidence rate of healthcare-associated VRE infection (cat. 1a + 1b) was 0.18/10,000 patient days (Table 2).  

In the health region of Montreal, teaching healthcare facilities have a threefold higher healthcare-associated incidence VRE infection rate than non teaching facilities (Table 2).

Table 2 – Incidence Rate and Percentile Distribution of Healthcare-Associated VRE Infection (Cat. 1a + 1b) by Type of Healthcare Facility, Québec, 2014–2015 (Incidence Rate per 10,000 Patient Days [95% CI])

Type of FacilityHealth regionMin.25%50%75%90%Max.Incidence Rate
Non-teaching (N = 7)06 health region0.150.150.190.410.410.410.16 [0.06 ; 0.31]
Teaching (N = 14)06 health region0.140.280.460.962.002.000.54 [0.42 ; 0.68]¥
Non-teaching (N = 56)Other health regions00.060.160.220.360.430.06 [0.03 ; 0.10]
Teaching (N = 12)Other health regions0.120.120.140.160.160.160.03 [0.01 ; 0.07]
Total (N = 89) 00.130.190.410.832.000.18 [0.14 ; 0.22]

[I.C. 95%] : 95% confidence interval.
¥ Significant statistical difference (p < 0.05) between non-teaching and teaching healthcare facilities form the health region of Montreal.

The incidence rate of healthcare-associated VRE infections in 2014-2015 was stable as compared to 2013-2014 (Table 3).

Table 3 – Change in Incidence Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE Infection (Cat. 1a + 1b) by Type of Healthcare Facility, Québec, 2011–2012 to 2014–2015 (Incidence Rate per 10,000 Patient Days [95% CI])

Type of FacilityHealth regionIncidence Rate 
2011-20122012-20132013-20142014-2015
Non-teaching (N = 7)06 health region0.28 [0.10 ; 0.55]0.10 [0.03 ; 0.22]0.13 [0.04 ; 0.27]0.16 [0.06 ; 0.31]
Teaching (N = 14)06 health region0.26 [0.16 ; 0.39]0.23 [0.16 ; 0.32]0.61 [0.48 ; 0.76]0.54 [0.42 ; 0.68]
Non-teaching (N = 56)Other health regions0.03 [0.01 ; 0.07]0.03 [0.01 ; 0.06]0.02 [0.01 ; 0.04]0.06 [0.03 ; 0.10]
Teaching (N = 12)Other health regions000.03 [0.01 ; 0.07]0.03 [0.01 ; 0.07]
Total (N = 89) 0.11 [0.07 ; 0.15]0.08 [0.06 ; 0.11]0.18 [0.14 ; 0.22]0.18 [0.14 ; 0.22]

NB: Facilities that have been analyzed are those participating in surveillance in 2014-2015 and at least 11 periods of each 2011-2012 to 2013-2014 years.

In total, 103 cases of VRE infection were reported: 91 (88.3%) were identified in patients who acquired VRE infection during a current hospital stay (84 patients), a previous hospital stay (3 patients) or in ambulatory care of the reporting facility (4 patients) (cat. 1a, 1b and 1c.). A total of 12 cases were associated to another facility, community or unknown (cat. 2, 3 and 4) (table 4). Among the 103 VRE infections, 63 infections were from known colonized cases. A total of 53 cases were of category 1a, 1 case of category 1b, 3 cases of category 1c, 5 cases of category 3 and 1 case of category 4.

Table 4 – Cases of VRE Infection by Presumed Source of Acquisition, Québec, 2014–2015 (N, %)

CategorySource of AcquisitionInfection
1aHealthcare-associated with a current hospital stay in the reporting facility84 (81.6%)
1bHealthcare-associated with a previous hospital stay in the reporting facility3 (2.9%)
1cHealthcare-associated with ambulatory care in the reporting facility4 (3.9%)
1dHealthcare-associated with long term unit in the reporting facility0 (0%)
2Healthcare-associated with another facility2 (1.9%)
3Community10 (9.7%)
4Unknown0 (0%)
 Total103

In 2014-2015, among 103 infections, 23 primary bloodstream infections (BSI) and 13 secondary bloodstream infections have been reported (Table 5).

Table 5 – Number of Cases of VRE Infection from All Sources by Type of Infection and Number of Complications (Secondary BSIs), Québec, 2014–2015 (N = 103)

Type of InfectionInfections
(N)
Secondary Bloodstream 
Infections (N)
Primary BSI  
   CRBSI-MBI1-
   CRBSI11-
   Non- CRBSI-MBI0-
   Non-CRBSI10-
   HD1-
   
Others  
   Urinary tract286
   Abdominal203
   Pulmonary00
   Surgical site131
   Skin and soft tissus173
   Bones and joints10
   Others1 
Total10313

BSI : bloodstream infection
CRBSI : catheter-related bloodstream infection
MBI : mucosal barrier injury
Non-CRBSI : non- catheter-related primary bloodstream infection
HD: hemodialysis

A total of 18 deaths within 30 days were observed, yielding a case fatality of 17.5% (Table 6). Since 2011-2012, the case fatality decreased from 19% to 17.5% (non significant).

Table 6 – Number of Deaths and 30-days case fatality Related to VRE Infection, Québec, 2011-2012 to 2014-2015

 2011-20122012-20132013-20142014-2015
VRE infections (all sources)63112109103
Number of deaths12211918
Case fatality19.0%18.8%17.4%17.5%

In 2014-2015, the acquisition rate of healthcare-associated VRE colonization (cat. 1a + 1b) was 10.99 / 10,000 patient days. In the health region of Montreal, the acquisition rate of healthcare-associated VRE colonization in teaching facilities was almost identical to the one in non-teaching facilities (Table 7).

Table 7 – Change in the Number of Cases and Acquisition rate of Healthcare-associated VRE colonization (Cat. 1a + 1b) by type of Healthcare facility, Québec, 2011-2012 à 2014-2015 (Acquisition rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE colonization per 10,000  patient days)

 Type of FacilityHealth region2011-20122012-20132013-20142014-2015
Number of Cases of ColonizationAcquisition Rate of HA-VRE ColonizationNumber of Cases of ColonizationAcquisition Rate of HA-VRE ColonizationNumber of Cases of ColonizationAcquisition Rate of HA-VRE ColonizationNumber of Cases of ColonizationAcquisition Rate of HA-VRE Colonization
Non-teaching (N = 7)06 HR38117.6369517.6986922.5687222.95
Teaching (N = 14)06 HR1,10414.572,45118.432,87122.762,53320.76
Non-teaching (N = 56)Other HR4093.537003.361,0895.261,6608.00
Teaching (N = 12)Other HR640.942992.484884.122522.17
Total (N = 89) 1,9586.964,1458.275,31710.855,31710.99

Table 8 shows the number of non teaching facilities that identified the type of screening used at admission (57 out of 63) and during hospitalization (57 out of 63). The majority of teaching facilities identified the type of screening used at admission (24 out of 26) and during hospitalization (24 out of 26). Only two facilities (one teaching and one non-teaching) did not identify the total type of screening.

Table 8 – Number of Healthcare Facilities that Identified the type of Screening Procedure Used at Admission and During Hospitalization by Type of Facility, Québec, 2014-2015

 Type of FacilityHealth 
region
Number of Facilities That Identified the Type of Screening Procedure Used*
At admissionDuring HospitalizationTotal
Non-teaching (N = 7)06 HR777
Teaching (N = 14)06 HR131313
Non-teaching (N = 56)Other HR505055
Teaching (N = 12)Other HR111112
Total (N = 89) 818187

* The number of facilities that reported the type of screening procedures used at admission and during hospitalization is not additive.
HR: Health region.

Tables 9 and 10 feature the total number of screening tests performed at admission and during hospitalization, as well as the mean number of VRE screening tests.

Table 9 – Total Number of Screening Tests Performed at Admission and During Hospitalization by Type of Healthcare Facility, Québec, 2014-2015

 Type of FacilityHealth 
region
Total Number of Screening Tests
At admission
(N)
During Hospitalization
(N)
Unspecified
(N)
Total
Non-teaching 06 HR22,912 (7)24,714 (7)2,750 (4)50,376 (7)
Teaching 06 HR34,486 (14)147,595 (13)1,293 (4)183,374 (14)
Non-teaching Other HR143,186 (54)143, 763 (54)39,931 (37)326,880 (56)
Teaching Other HR75,800 (11)86,421 (11)22,750 (3)184,971 (12)
Total 276,384 (86)402,493 (85)66,724 (48)745,601 (89)

Table 10 – Mean Number of VRE Screening Score by Type of Healthcare Facility, Québec, 2014-2015 (Mean VRE Screening Tests per Admission)

 Type of FacilityHealth 
region
Mean Number of VRE Screening Score*
At admission
(N)
During Hospitalization
(N)
Tota(N)
Non-teaching 06 HR0.57 (7)0.61 (7)1.24 (7)
Teaching 06 HR0.50 (13)0.50 (13)1.13 (13)
Non-teaching Other HR0.23 (50)0.97 (50)1.21 (55)
Teaching Other HR0.46 (11)0.53 (11)1.13 (12)
Total 0.43 (81)0.62 (81)1.16 (87)

*The mean numbers of VRE screening score at admission and during hospitalization are not additive.

The incidence rate of HA-VRE infection and the percentile rankings by type of facility are shown in Figure 1 and 2. Figures 3 and 4 feature the rate of acquisition and percentile ranking of HA-VRE colonization by type of facility.

Figure 1 – Incidence Rate and Percentile Ranking of Healthcare-Associated VRE infection (Cat. 1a + 1b) for Healthcare Facilities from the health region of Montreal, Québec, 2014-2015 (Incidence Rate per 10,000 Patient Days)

Figure 1 – Incidence Rate and Percentile Ranking of Healthcare-Associated VRE infection (Cat. 1a + 1b) for Healthcare Facilities from the health region of Montreal, Québec, 2014-2015 (Incidence Rate per 10,000 Patient Days)

NB : Facilities 6, 12, 13, 38, 48, 76, 80, 83, 116 and 118 did not report any cases of infection in 2014-2015.

Figure 2 – Incidence Rate and Percentile Ranking of Healthcare-Associated VRE infection (Cat. 1a + 1b) for Healthcare Facilities outside Heath Regions of Montreal, Québec, 2014-2015 (Incidence Rate per 10,000 Patient Days)

Figure 2 – Incidence Rate and Percentile Ranking of Healthcare-Associated VRE infection (Cat. 1a + 1b) for Healthcare Facilities outside Heath Regions of Montreal, Québec, 2014-2015 (Incidence Rate per 10,000 Patient Days)

NB : Facilities 2, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16, 18, 20, 23, 24, 27, 28, 30, 31, 32, 33, 37, 39, 40, 41, 44, 47, 49, 51, 52, 53, 56, 59, 61, 63, 64, 65, 67, 70, 71, 72, 74, 75, 77, 81, 82, 84, 85, 86, 88, 89, 91, 95, 96, 97, 99, 103, 107, 109, 111, 112, 113 and 130 did not report any cases of infection in 2014-2015.

Figure 3 – Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE Colonization (Cat.1a + 1b) in Healthcare Facilities from the health region of Montreal, Québec, 2014-2015 (Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE colonization per 10,000 patient days)

Figure 3 – Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE Colonization (Cat.1a + 1b) in Healthcare Facilities from the health region of Montreal, Québec, 2014-2015 (Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE colonization per 10,000 patient days)

NB : Facilities 6 and 12 did not report any cases of infection in 2014-2015.

Figure 4 – Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE Colonization (Cat.1a + 1b) in Healthcare Facilities outside Heath Regions of Montreal, Québec, 2014-2015 (Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE colonization per 10,000 patient days)

Figure 4 – Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE Colonization (Cat.1a + 1b) in Healthcare Facilities outside Heath Regions of Montreal, Québec, 2014-2015 (Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE colonization per 10,000 patient days)

NB : Facilities 23, 49, 53, 61, 64, 67, 71, 72, 75, 85, 86, 88, 89, 91, 97, 107, 109 and 112 did not report any cases of infection in 2014‑2015.

At the local level, in 2014-2015, the incidence rate of HA-VRE infection ranged from 0 to 2.00 * 10,000 patient days, whereas the acquisition rate of HA-VRE colonization ranged from 0 to 63.05 / 10,000 patient days. A total of 20 facilities (22.5%) did not report any HA-VRE infection or colonization in 2014-2015. A detailed summary of the surveillance data for HA-VRE infection by healthcare facility can be found in Table 11.

Table 11 – Incidence Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE Infection (cat. 1a + 1b), Acquisition Rate of Healthcare-Associated VRE Colonization and Mean VRE Screening Tests by Admission and by Facility, Québec, 2014-2015 (Incidence Rate per 10,000 patient days [95% CI]; Acquisition Rate of Colonization per 10,000 patient days)

Health
Region
FacilityIncidence Rate of HA-VRE Infection (cat. 1a + 1b) 
[95% CI]
Acquisition Rate of HA-VRE Colonization 
(cat. 1a + 1b)
Mean VRE Screening Tests per Admission*
NumberName
0116HÔPITAL RÉGIONAL DE RIMOUSKI00.381.05
32CENTRE HOSPITALIER RÉGIONAL DU GRAND-PORTAGE00.361.16
61HÔPITAL NOTRE-DAME-DE-FATIMA000.43
71HÔPITAL DE MATANE001.14
77HÔPITAL D’AMQUI02.292.23
84HÔPITAL DE NOTRE-DAME-DU-LAC011.192.02
 BAS-SAINT-LAURENT01.221.19
0220HÔPITAL DE CHICOUTIMI00.730.67
67HÔPITAL ET CENTRE DE RÉADAPTATION DE JONQUIÈRE000.84
74HÔPITAL DE DOLBEAU-MISTASSINI01.280.79
88HÔPITAL, CLSC ET CENTRE D’HÉBERGEMENT DE ROBERVAL000.82
112HÔPITAL D’ALMA000.48
 SAGUENAY–LAC-SAINT-JEAN00.410.69
032HÔPITAL DE L’ENFANT-JÉSUS02.051.28
7PAVILLON L’HÔTEL-DIEU DE QUÉBEC0.12 [0-0.47]3.462.27
24HÔPITAL DU SAINT-SACREMENT00.741.39
27PAVILLON CENTRE HOSPITALIER DE L’UNIVERSITÉ LAVAL00.081.08
28PAVILLON SAINT-FRANÇOIS D’ASSISE07.701.51
33INST. UNIV. DE CARDIO. ET DE PNEUMO. DE QUÉBEC02.991.89
59HÔPITAL DE BAIE-SAINT-PAUL08.181.44
86HÔPITAL DE LA MALBAIE001.05
 CAPITALE-NATIONALE0.02 [0-0.07]2.791.50
0423HÔTEL-DIEU D’ARTHABASKA001.11
31PAVILLON SAINT-JOSEPH00.311.28
41HÔPITAL DU CENTRE-DE-LA-MAURICIE02.251.61
44HÔPITAL SAINTE-CROIX01.40-
85CSSS DU HAUT-SAINT-MAURICE000.50
 MAURICIE ET CENTRE-DU-QUÉBEC00.771.01
0515HÔPITAL FLEURIMONT00.370.39
30HÔTEL-DIEU DE SHERBROOKE00.150.49
49CSSS DE MEMPHRÉMAGOG000.89
75CSSS DU GRANIT000.05
 ESTRIE00.250.42
063HÔPITAL ROYAL VICTORIA2.00 [1.25-2.92]29.050.72
4HÔPITAL NOTRE-DAME DU CHUM0.27 [0.05-0.66]12.251.78
5HÔPITAL GÉNÉRAL JUIF1.08 [0.63-1.66]22.980.52
6HÔPITAL DE MONTRÉAL POUR ENFANTS000.05
8PAV. MAISONNEUVE / PAV. MARCEL-LAMOUREUX0.38 [0.15-0.71]20.811.07
12CENTRE HOSPITALIER UNIVERSITAIRE SAINTE-JUSTINE00-
13INSTITUT DE CARDIOLOGIE DE MONTRÉAL04.882.01
21HÔPITAL SAINT-LUC DU CHUM0.29 [0.05-0.72]9.731.84
22HÔTEL-DIEU DU CHUM0.14 [0-0.54]16.253.06
25HÔPITAL DU SACRÉ-CœUR DE MONTRÉAL0.53 [0.19-1.04]58.171.89
26HÔPITAL DE VERDUN0.41 [0.08-1.01]57.801.01
29HÔPITAL GÉNÉRAL DE MONTRÉAL0.83 [0.33-1.56]31.591.24
34HÔPITAL SANTA CABRINI0.19 [0.02-0.55]6.381.14
36HÔPITAL GÉNÉRAL DU LAKESHORE0.15 [0-0.58]35.841.63
38HÔPITAL JEAN-TALON04.961.39
48CENTRE HOSPITALIER DE ST. MARY015.721.49
76HÔPITAL DE LACHINE021.021.87
80HÔPITAL FLEURY013.941.48
83HÔPITAL DE LASALLE07.140.38
116INSTITUT THORACIQUE DE MONTRÉAL022.561.75
118HÔPITAL NEUROLOGIQUE DE MONTRÉAL02.021.35
 MONTRÉAL0.45 [0.35-0.56]21.281.22
0739HÔPITAL DE GATINEAU011.470.67
40HÔPITAL DE HULL024.812.67
51HÔPITAL DE MANIWAKI04.871.33
95HÔPITAL DU PONTIAC03.261.75
111HÔPITAL DE PAPINEAU063.051.98
 OUTAOUAIS020.991.54
0847HÔPITAL DE ROUYN-NORANDA00.400.14
52CENTRE HOSPITALIER HÔTEL-DIEU D’AMOS00.450.04
65HÔPITAL ET CLSC DE VAL-D’OR011.340.62
70CENTRE DE SOINS DE COURTE DURÉE LA SARRE01.971.07
82PAVILLON SAINTE-FAMILLE01.340.53
 ABITIBI-TÉMISCAMINGUE03.960.40
0964HÔPITAL LE ROYER000.07
72HÔPITAL ET CENTRE D’HÉBERGEMENT DE SEPT-ÎLES000.08
 CÔTE-NORD000.08
1096CENTRE DE SANTÉ DE CHIBOUGAMAU02.930.69
 NORD-DU-QUÉBEC02.930.69
1153HÔPITAL DE CHANDLER000.75
91HÔPITAL HÔTEL-DIEU DE GASPÉ000.38
97HÔPITAL DE MARIA001.42
107HÔPITAL DE L’ARCHIPEL000.66
109HÔPITAL DE SAINTE-ANNE-DES-MONTS000.80
 GASPÉSIE–ÎLES-DE-LA-MADELEINE000.90
1218HÔTEL-DIEU DE LÉVIS00.130.59
63HÔPITAL DE SAINT-GEORGES00.990.65
89HÔPITAL DE MONTMAGNY001.12
113HÔPITAL DE THETFORD MINES00.380.86
 CHAUDIÈRE-APPALACHES00.370.72
1319HÔPITAL CITÉ DE LA SANTÉ0.06 [0-0.23]2.410.73
 LAVAL0.06 [0-0.23]2.410.73
1411HÔPITAL PIERRE-LE GARDEUR00.270.90
14CENTRE HOSPITALIER RÉGIONAL DE LANAUDIÈRE01.891.68
 LANAUDIÈRE01.021.25
1545HÔPITAL DE SAINT-EUSTACHE0.22 [0.02-0.63]4.211.23
56CSSS D’ARGENTEUIL03.122.87
81HÔPITAL DE MONT-LAURIER013.361.91
101HÔPITAL RÉGIONAL DE SAINT-JÉRÔME0.18 [0.02-0.51]25.681.97
103HÔPITAL LAURENTIEN014.041.56
 LAURENTIDES0.15 [0.04-0.33]15.111.68
161HÔPITAL CHARLES-LEMOYNE0.16 [0.02-0.45]6.021.23
9HÔPITAL DU HAUT-RICHELIEU0.12 [0-0.46]7.931.26
10HÔPITAL PIERRE-BOUCHER017.190.53
35HÔPITAL HONORÉ-MERCIER0.29 [0.03-0.83]22.611.59
37HÔTEL-DIEU DE SOREL01.441.73
42HÔPITAL ANNA-LABERGE0.13 [0-0.52]34.472.42
46HÔPITAL DE GRANBY0.43 [0.04-1.23]10.691.74
58HÔPITAL DU SUROÎT0.18 [0-0.70]3.381.35
99HÔPITAL BROME-MISSISQUOI-PERKINS01.071.29
130HÔPITAL BARRIE MEMORIAL05.071.70
 MONTÉRÉGIE0.14 [0.06-0.24]12.591.32
  Total0.18 [0.14-0.22]10.991.16

*   Number of screening test divided by number of admissions.

Comité de surveillance provinciale des infections nosocomiales (SPIN)

Editorial committee 

Christophe Garenc, Direction des risques biologiques et de la santé au travail, Institut national de santé publique du Québec

Muleka Ngenda-Muadi, Direction des risques biologiques et de la santé au travail, Institut national de santé publique du Québec

Mélissa Trudeau, Direction des risques biologiques et de la santé au travail, Institut national de santé publique du Québec

Patrice Vigeant, CISSS de la Montérégie-Ouest - Hôpital du Suroît